1

So there were pending edits, which I rejected, to remove from the following questions:

What medium should be kept beneath the paper for papercutting?

and

What is a proper tool for papercutting?

Under the tags page the second sentence reads:

Using the right tags makes it easier for others to find and answer your question.

The first is asking what they should be cutting paper on where the second is asking about what tool to use to cut paper.

seems very appropriate in both cases. OK so perhaps the argument is that renders redundant. The community might see otherwise and remove them.

What actual harm is caused by that tag being there? I would argue, at a minimum, that gives those questions more visibility. I don't think it makes the question worse.

2

Paper tags should be for questions about paper... not questions that just happen to involve paper.

The questions are not asking for help selecting paper, they're asking for help picking out a knife/blade and a mat...

Papercutting in itself implies paper. Why do we need both and on all questions about paper cutting? The tags are redundant.

3
  • It is a valid argument I just don't know what bad could come of them being there. Do we even really need paper then? Something else like origami also implies paper. Would there be questions about paper that don't involve a craft-like tag? I'm just curious is all. – Matt Apr 30 '16 at 0:59
  • 1
    Questions about drawing or watercolors could easily need a paper tag if someone is attempting to pick the correct type of paper to use. – Catija Apr 30 '16 at 1:00
  • Ah yes that would be true since you don't exclusively draw on paper. Good point. – Matt Apr 30 '16 at 1:00

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .